First, I had to find the meaning of the unusual title. Muskoka is a municipality two hours north of Toronto, and Maharani is a princess in India. This all makes complete sense after finishing the book, which is set basically in and around a fictitious little Anglo-Indian railway colony in pre-Indepence east India. The term Anglo-Indian, during the colonial era, was used to refer to those people who were of strictly British descent, but were born and raised in India, usually because their parents were serving in the colonial administration or armed forces.
The thing I like best about this book, is that it's peppered with charming details of Anglo-Indian life in the 1930s. McMahon, who was raised in India himself, masterfully conveys these unique first hand bits of culture and domesticity. In fact, I found myself wishing he had included more of them. There is one lovely scene in particular, in which the servant woman would use the ash, leftover from the previous day's fire, to make a paste to wash the dishes. "...Jeera would rinse everything in the sink. Then, taking some of the ash in her right hand, she would rub it carefully across the wet surface of the first piece of cutlery and crockery...every square inch of the object she was washing....before giving the item one final rinse under the water to leave the surface looking as good as new."
Towards the end of the book, the story shifts to 1940 England, were Serena is a nurse, enlisted into Churchill's Special Operations Executive. I especially enjoyed these chapters, which take on a bit of a Charlotte Gray feel, and actually wish more detail had been devoted to these intriguing war time events surrounding Dunkirk.
Sixty years later, the revelation of Serena's secret, (a spoiler, so I can't tell) takes Harry Barnsley to Vatican City. Even though I feel the surprise ending is just a tad outlandish, Muskoka Maharani is a well written, interesting read, set in a place and time in India, which I previously knew very little about.
I had seen this book in your reading list and was curious. I visit the Muskoka region every summer. It's breathtakingly beautiful. :-)
ReplyDelete(and fine book review - and the story sounds wonderful.)
ReplyDeletegreat book review willow...honest and insightful...good to see david again as well...even if it is not at authorblog...will look this one up.
ReplyDeleteThis does sound intriguing.
ReplyDeleteAnd I live just a few hours from the Muskoka are.
It sounds like my kind of adventure. I will put it on my list. I miss Authorblog, David was always very encouraging.
ReplyDeleteButternut, I adore David. He is sorely missed in the blogosphere. From what I hear, he's busy at work on his next novel!
ReplyDeleteAn interesting review and if I have learned anything from following your blog and posts it is that I'm sure I will like whatever you recommend.
ReplyDeleteOh, and I'm glad you did the leg work on the meaning of the title. . .
Here we go again. You may well know that here in Canada we have just finished hosting the G8 debacle of world leaders in "The Muskoka's" as they are affectionately know in these parts. I have just spent the past week looking into Indian attire to wear to the wedding of a dear friend's son. Your review is amazing. This will be my next read. Same wavelength???
ReplyDeleteLeslie, we are connected with some kind of unusual synchronicity!
ReplyDeletewell written review of what sounds like an unusual book maybe you could review for the NYTimes?
ReplyDeleteI loved the Indian setting of David's previous book Vindaloo Vegemite
ReplyDeleteand am certain this one will have many treasures too.
I look forward to reading it.
I spied David's book on your reading list some time ago and was looking forward to read your review. Thank you and congratulations to David, may this new novel hit the bestseller lists and stay there for a long time!
ReplyDeletegreat review - and another book to go in my stack of first come first read's - thanks so much for such a fantastic review of what sounds like a great book!
ReplyDeleteGreat review, willow. Thorough and honest. Really intriguing story! Thank you.
ReplyDeleteI always enjoy anything about colonial India, and the Indian culture is endlessly fascinating, so it sounds like an interesting read on many fronts. It also sounds as if it covers a lot of ground! Thanks for the review. I wish him great success with his book.
ReplyDeleteI always enjoy reading about places I've never been. And if a good story come with it, well, so much the better!
ReplyDeleteDavid has so much respect throughout blogland, and you do too, so it is appropriate that he asked you to read his book. Thanks for the information and the recommendation.
ReplyDeleteALWAYS interesting. ALWAYS a pleasure
ReplyDeleteand sometimes a challenge, no time to read a book this week (Ha! nor last week, etc..) I must be a loser in the category of authors and titles. (And I do NOT watch TV--EVER!).
THANK YOU for driving over to steveroni (on your keyboard--grin!)
And YESSSS, I hear each time all those "other" little "get on your kneesies" as they build into a crescendo, nearly into a trance-like state of being, for the listener.
See ya next week--or before! I AM taking my computer, rather IT is taking ME!
I think it sounds wonderful. Of course, I am drawn to anything that even has a hint of India in it so I will keep an eye out for this book. It sounds like it is not yet available in an easy manner for purchase, though.
ReplyDeleteSounds like my sort of book. I find Anglo-Indian backgrounds totally fascinating.
ReplyDeleteSounds like a really good read - just the thing for cold winters day.
ReplyDeleteIt sounds as if it covers a period I too find fascinating. I will certainly keep a look out for it.
ReplyDeleteHi Willow:
ReplyDeleteThanks for the book review. It really sounds like an excellent reading about India, Canada, Great Britain and the Vatican.
Congrats!
Omar.-
Dear Willow: Are you discussing the same "Muskoka"? Is there a Muskoka in India? That is really synchronistic. Yes I was noticing the book for awhile now and thought "nah, it cannot be the same Muskoka". Now for the dumb question: Is it Muskoka Ontario or is it Muskoka India? Sounds like a great read! Wonders if he writes a bit like Michael Ondaatje who is Canadian-Sri Lankan also a famous author.
ReplyDeleteChicco, yes, like I mention in the post, it's the Muskoka two hours north of Toronto!
ReplyDeleteWillow,
ReplyDeleteA good review! Sounds like this one is ready for the screenplay!
We can get Maggie Smith and Judi Dench worked in there some way with Toby Stephens as Harry Barnsley....
:) The Bach
Bach, it would make a great movie. Yes, the dreamy Toby Stephens would be perfect as Harry Barnsley!
ReplyDeleteI have made a note of the title willow - sounds an interesting book.
ReplyDeleteHello Willow,
ReplyDeleteAlthough I was familiar with the two names in the title, one wouldn't readily put them together, which adds a little intrigue for the reader. The location shifts must add interest too. I hope David has a success with it.
This is very interesting to me because my Auntie Prue (my father's brother's wife) is an Anglo-Indian. Her father was a Colonel and she and her sister were born in India. She often told me stories of her childhood in India. She is a charming, lovely woman now in her 70's. I especially remember that my Aunt could really relate to the little Anglo-Indian girl, Mary Lennox, in the book The Secret Garden. Auntie Prue, like Mary, had been sent to England from her birth place, India, for the first time at around age nine.
ReplyDeleteThis book sounds like a "must" read for me....
ReplyDeleteI trust your taste!
Hugs,
♥ Robin ♥
Very cool! You could also have a career as a book reviewer. I kind of like you better as a poet, but that's just me.
ReplyDeleteLove "Manor Macro." Yep.
Sounds like an interesting book, Willow, one that I would really like to read. And how wonderful of you to review your friend's book, and not just that, but give an honest and articulate analysis too! :)
ReplyDeletewillow all your posts and your blog link have disappeared from my blogroll. odd. Oh wait, I was looking for Willow Manor and forgot the Life at. Anyway, yes, I placed a Poets cookbook in my amazon cart though I havent put the order through yet and it was very hard to only order one. Great gift for all my poet friends. but maybe another time. Thanks again!!
ReplyDeleteforget what I just said. I found you on my blogroll. must be a summer heat faint.
ReplyDeleteSounds intriguing - I've been fascinated by colonial India since watching "A Jewel in the Crown" and "A Passage to India" when I was a youngin'.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I've been meaning to tell you how much I adore the portrait you've used for a header. Is it one you own? Is it a relative?
Thanks, Rochelle, it's by the artist Meredith Frampton. Here's something I posted on him a few weeks ago...
ReplyDeletehttp://willowmanor.blogspot.com/2010/06/my-latest-crush.html
I'm in need of a new read and this one has piqued my interested. Thanks for the intuitive review.
ReplyDeleteWillow amazing story - there is the female spy from Magpie Tales the week before last and - also my husband is from that area in Canada....thank you for the review I may have to pick it up and give it a read....sounds wonderful...bkm
ReplyDeleteGlad I popped into blogland today and spotted your review of David's book. And what a wonderful review it is Willow; I look forward to reading the book.
ReplyDeleteJane
This sounds to be my kind of book. A must read added to my list.
ReplyDeleteOf late I have been reading books about India and found them to be quite enjoyable. I will be adding this to my next shopping list. Thanks, Willow, for an excellent review.
ReplyDeleteVery humbly, may I say a deep and sincere thank you to you, Willow, for taking the time to read the book and review it.
ReplyDeleteI was actually travelling on US soil (with my family) when you posted the review, so I wasn't aware it had been posted until I returned home.
I'm so glad you found a Charlotte Grey feel to the wartime segment - there was a lot to compress into those chapters.
Just as Brian Miller said in the third comment, your review was honest and insightful and I thank you for it.
Muskoka took my breath away when I first visited (and photographed) the area in Setember 2005. Everything I describe in the area is exactly as I saw it back then, even down to the opening sunrise across the lake.
My thanks, too, to the many people who have commented on this review. It's extremely touching to know how much support a simple novel can find in BlogLand.
Thank you, all of you.
David
David, it was a pleasure, my friend. I'm looking forward to your next book with great anticipation!
ReplyDelete